I have been delving into the world of prebiotics lately and wanted to update my thinking on this subject from the last article.
Previously I was concerned with the idea of feeding potentially pathogenic or less than friendly microorganisms with the use of prebiotic foods and supplements but after looking into the subject more extensively I am less concerned.
The question – Do prebiotics, including fermentable oligosaccharides, galactooligosaccharides and lactulose increase intestinal dysregulation for those who already have dysbiosis is one that I have been thinking on for quite some time. The answer becomes clearer when we actually drill down to what a prebiotic is actually defined as. A number of different researchers have had a go at defining it. One that stands out to me is as follows
“A prebiotic is a non-digestible food ingredient that beneficially affects the host by selectively stimulating the growth and/or activity of one or a limited number of bacteria in the colon, and thus improves host health (2)”
The same paper goes on to list the four key points that a food must have to be considered a prebiotic
- It cannot be digestible or absorbed in the small intestine. Basically it must completely escape digestion.
- It must very selectively feed a small number of beneficial bacteria that inhabit our large intestine.
- As a result of the selective feeding prebiotics shift the colonic flora in a healthy way. Basically feeding the beneficial microflora to the detriment of the pathogenic microbes
- As a result of the beneficial shift in the microbiomes residents, consumption of prebiotics are responsible for beneficial for the host
All are valuable points on the subject of prebiotics and gut health. For me the third point is the most important and brings me to a point that I hadn’t fully understood in the last article.
What is the difference between colonic foods and prebiotics.
Prebiotics selectively feed a small number of beneficial microbes in the gut whereas colonic foods feed whatever is there.
A Range of Prebiotics
There are two very popular prebiotics, fructooligosaccharides and galactooligosaccharides, and a third one, lactulose, that is not quite as popular in the research but may be worth exploring for its benefits.
Today we will cover fructooligosaccharides and save both galactooligosaccharides and lactulose for their separate articles.
FOS – Fructooligosaccharides
Fructooligosaccharides have been well researched with a range of different human studies looking into the benefits of use.
One review found in a range of different foods including barley, tomatoes, onion, bananas, brown sugar, rye, garlic and honey fructooligosaccharides promote the growth of Bifidobacterium and actually have an inhibitory effect on Clostridium perfringens, listed as being one of the top causes of food poisoning in the United States (4).
The first review referenced proposed the concept of a lowered pH in the colon, caused by the the growth of Bifidobacteria which then produced an abundance of acetate and lactate, as being one mechanism for the inhibitory effects on genera including Bacteroides and Clostridia.
They continued to speculate on other mechanisms of inhibition of pathogens caused by a boost in the beneficial Bifidobacteria in the colon. Particularly the possibilities that Bifidobacteria might secrete an antimicrobial bacteriocin-like substance. With this in mind it is interesting to note the decrease in Bacteroides, Clostridia and Fusobacteria that went along with a marked increase in Bifidobacteria seen in a human trial cited by the same review.
While it is true that there are members of Bacteroides, Clostridia and Fusobacteria that are non-pathogenic, and even beneficial, it is worth noting that all three genera contain some seriously problematic and pathogenic species.
The other two prebiotics that I will be covering in future articles show similar effects in selectively boosting very specific beneficial bacteria in the colon but are different in their own way.
In the previous article on prebiotics I was concerned about feeding pathogenic microbes for people that are suffering from dysbiosis and recommended a functional stool sample before moving into a gut rebuilding phase. I still hold this opinion for colonic foods, including partially hydrolyzed guar gum, psyllium husks and resistant starches.
I am now less concerned about the classic prebiotic supplements such as FOS, GOS and lactulose, unless, and this is a pretty big unless, SIBO is present. If SIBO is present then all bets are off and the overgrowth needs to be cleared before moving onto correcting imbalances in the large bowel. More on SIBO here – SIBO: The Complete Guide